Article 4 of 18 in the series “Edward F. Hills and the Logic of Faith: Presuppositional Apologetics and the Biblical Text.”
Cornelius Van Til did not write a handbook of New Testament textual criticism. Edward F. Hills saw that Van Til’s apologetic nevertheless had consequences for every manuscript, variant, canon, and reconstruction in the discipline.
The connection begins with a simple claim: human reasoning is never religiously neutral. Every person knows the God who made him, yet the fallen mind suppresses that knowledge and seeks to interpret reality as though it were independent of God. The Christian, renewed by grace, must learn to think God’s thoughts after him. Scripture does not stand before autonomous reason as one possible authority among others. It is the self-attesting Word by which every lesser claim is judged.
If that account of knowledge is true, the textual critic cannot temporarily become neutral when he opens a manuscript. The identity of the document, the meaning of its history, and the possibility of knowing its text all belong within the conflict between belief and unbelief.
Van Til’s Relevant Principles
Several features of Van Til’s apologetic supplied Hills with his methodological grammar.
First, there are no brute facts. A manuscript leaf is real, its ink has an age, its readings have a history, and its scribe acted within providence. The physical object does not explain itself. To call it a neutral datum is already to conceal the interpretive framework within which it is being placed.
Second, the unbeliever possesses genuine knowledge by common grace. Van Til’s rejection of neutrality does not imply that only Christians can measure a parchment, identify a hand, or collate a reading. Hills repeatedly relied on information assembled by critics whose theology he rejected. The antithesis concerns the ultimate interpretation and integration of facts, not the unbeliever’s inability to know anything.
Third, authority is inescapable. A critic who refuses to begin with God’s revelation does not begin without authority. He treats human judgment, critical consensus, or a chosen historical model as the court before which Scripture must be authenticated. Hills regarded this as an inversion: the servant becomes judge of the divine Word.
Fourth, method and conclusion cannot be sealed off from each other. A method that excludes inspiration and providence is not made Christian merely because an orthodox conclusion is attached at the end. For Hills, the Christian must begin, continue, and end as a Christian.
The Claim of a Common Method
Many conservative textual critics proposed a division of labor. Believers and unbelievers could use the same critical method because manuscripts are public evidence. Once the best text had been reconstructed, believers could add the theological confession that this text was inspired and providentially preserved.
Hills agreed that the evidence is public. He denied that its interpretation can be religiously common in the required sense. Consider the question, “What sort of history should we expect the New Testament text to have?” A critic who brackets revelation may expect accident, loss, local competition, and survival conditioned only by ordinary historical forces. A Christian may recognize those ordinary causes while also expecting God’s special providence to accomplish his revealed purpose for the Church.
The two critics may inspect the same witnesses, but they do not ask the same ultimate question. One asks which hypothetical ancestry best explains the surviving readings. The other also asks how the history fulfills God’s promise to preserve and supply his Word to his people. Hills’s point is not that the first question is illegitimate. It is that the first cannot be made the whole inquiry without prejudging the second.
Is This Fideism?
The standard objection is that Hills has replaced evidence with a theological conclusion. If the Textus Receptus is identified in advance as the preserved text, what work remains for criticism? Has faith become a device for insulating preferred readings from examination?
The objection identifies a genuine danger, but it does not refute the basic method. Every historical inquiry operates with prior convictions about reality, causation, testimony, and knowledge. Naturalism is not the absence of those commitments. The Christian is entitled—indeed obligated—to reason from what God has revealed.
The proper question is whether the specific inference has been established. “Scripture is providentially preserved” is not identical with “every reading of this printed edition is correct.” A Van Tilian method may be sound while a particular application is insufficiently demonstrated. Hills’s argument therefore requires both theological sympathy and critical discrimination.
This distinction is decisive. Presuppositionalism does not grant immunity from exegesis, history, or logical analysis. It orders those tasks beneath divine revelation. A Christian may challenge Hills’s identification of the preserved text without accepting religious neutrality, just as he may challenge a fellow Calvinist’s interpretation without surrendering the authority of Scripture.
The Self-Attesting Word and Its Text
Hills’s boldest move was to connect the self-attestation of Scripture with the present textual form known by the Church. A self-attesting Word that exists only in inaccessible autographs cannot perform its canonical function directly. The Church must possess Scripture in transmitted Hebrew and Greek texts and in faithful translations.
This insight exposes a tension in evangelical bibliology. Theological formulations may ascribe perfection to the original manuscripts while practical confidence rests on an eclectic reconstruction whose readings remain revisable. The believer is told that Scripture is the highest authority, yet the verbal content of that authority is sometimes presented as the provisional result of a discipline that recognizes no revealed starting point.
Hills responded by making present possession central. The preserved text is not an archaeological object waiting to be discovered after centuries of ecclesiastical absence. It is the text used, confessed, copied, printed, and received among God’s people.
That answer moves beyond Van Til. Van Til’s epistemology requires the authority of Scripture; it does not by itself identify the Textus Receptus. Hills supplied a doctrine of textual history to complete the argument. Whether that completion succeeds will occupy later articles.
An Application Van Til Did Not Make
The historical importance of Hills lies partly in this act of extension. He perceived that an apologetic used to expose neutrality in philosophy, science, and higher criticism must also reach lower criticism. The fact that textual criticism works with handwritten copies does not exempt it from the religious character of thought.
John H. Skilton later made the connection explicit. Men who accept the Bible as God’s inerrant Word, he argued, should not practice textual criticism neutrally; a person decides for or against God at every stage of investigation. Skilton credited both Van Til for stressing the general point and Hills for applying it appropriately to textual criticism.
Yet Skilton did not follow Hills to all his textual conclusions. That difference illustrates the enduring issue. Van Til’s apologetic can govern textual criticism without mechanically producing one edition. Hills’s pioneering achievement was to insist on the government. His controversial achievement was to claim that the “logic of faith” leads through ecclesiastical history to a particular textual settlement.
The first achievement should not be abandoned merely because the second needs examination.
Editorial source note
The direct link among Van Til, Hills, and textual criticism is stated in Theodore Letis’s 1983 preface to The King James Version Defended, which reproduces John H. Skilton’s 1982 assessment. Hills’s own introduction describes the conflict between Christian and modern presuppositions. Letis’s historical study supplies Hills’s retrospective explanation that Van Til’s apologetics enabled his critique of Warfield.
Previous: Article 3, “From Critical Initiate to Christian Textual Critic.” Next: Article 5, “Before the Defense: Hills’s Technical Textual Work.”



Comments
Share a question or response to this article.